Content of ExpertWritings and Theoretical Thinking in our journal

  • Published in last 1 year
  • In last 2 years
  • In last 3 years
  • All

Please wait a minute...
  • Select all
    |
  • ExpertWritings and Theoretical Thinking
    CAI Xiao-mei, SU Yang, WU Bi-hu, WANG Yi, YANG Rui, XU Wei-hua, MIN Qing-wen, ZHANG Hai-xia
    JOURNAL OF NATURAL RESOURCES. 2023, 38(4): 839-861. https://doi.org/10.31497/zrzyxb.20230401

    The establishment of the nature protected area system based on national parks is seen as the important implementation of Xi Jinping's Thought on ecological civilization from the perspective of reform. From the perspective of homeland space governance, it is the core carrier of ecological construction and the primary position of maintaining its primary position in national ecological security. In order to achieve harmonious coexistence between man and nature in the nature protected area, it is necessary to achieve "the strictest protection" and "lucid waters and lush mountains are invaluable assets", which is both ecological and civilized. In order to better understand and interpret the development of China's protected areas and the driving factors behind them in the context of ecological civilization construction, we invited seven well-known experts from ecological civilization and national park related fields to discuss the following aspects of the protected areas: ecological civilization construction, human-land relations, conflict and symbiotic transformation mechanism between man and nature, the governance system of the protected areas and the contribution of Chinese governance system to the construction of global ecological civilization, natural resource asset property rights system, daily management and supervision of the protected areas, ecological compensation and concession of the protected areas, and etc.

    The main conclusions are: (1) Only through establishing the ecological civilization system can local governments deal with the relationship between the protection and development of the protected areas, and the establishment of the national park system has made the fastest overall progress and is the most systematic part in the reform of the ecological civilization system. (2) To achieve the "strictest protection", the development of the protected areas is inseparable from the support of the concept of the human-land relations. It stresses on the importance of paying attention to the "land" of the nature protected area, as well as emphasize the significance of the functions and participation of people from the perspectives of "adapting measures to local conditions" and "authenticity of land lovers". (3) The institutional causes of human-nature conflict in the nature protected area mainly stem from the conflict of interests and structures between governments at different levels. (4) To resolve conflicts and achieve symbiosis between man and nature, it is necessary to optimize the governance system, especially adjust the responsibility and rights system of governments at all levels. Moreover, in order to achieve the goals of "ecological protection first" and "public welfare for all people", we should reconstruct the dimension of interests, and form a community of common interests. (5) It is necessary to coordinate and efficiently allocate the responsibilities and rights of different stakeholders under the unified management goals, and construct a co-governance pattern and pluralistic co-governance system of the nature protected area so as to handle various relationships of multiple subjects in the governance system of the nature protected area. (6) There are deep-seated contradictions between the logic of capital and ecology, between the protected areas and human settlements systems, between nature conservation goals and global execution. The institutional advantages of socialism with Chinese characteristics in the new era and the cultural tradition of "man and heaven" formed by thousands of years of accumulation can contribute Chinese wisdom to the construction of global ecological civilization. (7) In view of the construction needs of the protected areas system and its positioning in the spatial planning, it is necessary to optimize the property rights system of natural resource assets, and explore the control system of the territorial space that is conducive to handling the relationship between protection and development. Before the reform of the national institutions, there was a problem of fragmented management ("Nine-Dragon Water Governing" in Chinese) in the protected areas. The daily comprehensive management and supervision and law enforcement of the protected areas have been carried out to realize the unification, standardization and orderliness of management and supervision after the institutional reform. (8) In order to achieve ecological protection goals, it is necessary to universally realize the transformation of "two mountain theory", especially under the market economy. The national concession system can be seen as a market-oriented and diversified ecological compensation path and an effective way of green development, which requires the exploration of governmental franchise and brand franchising in active and diverse means.

  • ExpertWritings and Theoretical Thinking
    HE Si-yuan, MIN Qing-wen
    JOURNAL OF NATURAL RESOURCES. 2023, 38(4): 862-873. https://doi.org/10.31497/zrzyxb.20230402

    This research proposed a concept of conservation-compatible livelihoods (CCLs) and a systematic implementation approach based on the conservation-compatible idea and the "people-oriented" conservation policies and practices. A large number of case studies, plans, and management policies of protected areas with the key element of "conservation-compatible" were screened, and analysed in an inductive way to review the sustainable livelihoods in protected areas. This process led to the proposal of CCLs. The CCLs return to the reciprocity of humans and nature and are centered on the shift of the global conservation discourse from "fortress conservation" to "community conservation". We defined CCLs as the way of making a living from natural resource use and management, and production and operation based on or dominated by certain rural land use in the social-ecological system composed of the protected areas and their boundary communities. We identified four groups of CCL activities and summarised their major features concerning the ecological, economic, cultural and social aspects. Aiming at synergising local resource use and global biodiversity conservation, we suggested a triple-judgement approach for the conservation agency and local government to help communities to achieve CCLs, namely, the identification of the livelihood demands, whether they are compatible with conservation targets, and whether their economic returns are acceptable. We further constructed a master model of the mechanism of the conservation-compatible livelihood approach and illustrated how to reach a fair and sustainable rural livelihood through sustainable resource use and value-adding processes based on local resource endowment and multi-stakeholder participation. This mechanism also confirmed the application of the CCL approach beyond the scope of protected areas to a larger conservation network. We argued that the CCL approach is feasible concerning the on-going institutional changes in China, and promoting conservation-compatible livelihoods in conservation practices is very supportive to coordinate rural development and protected area management, and to secure the development needs of developing countries when they are taking great responsibility in global biodiversity conservation causes. Finally, we pointed out that it is necessary to apply the CCL approach in other effective area-based conservation measures (OECMs) at the landscape scale to enrich the way to achieve CCL and expand the appropriate spatial areas. Tracking the progress of CCLs and evaluating their outcomes are also important.

  • ExpertWritings and Theoretical Thinking
    ZHANG Chao-zhi, WU Hui, DU Jie
    JOURNAL OF NATURAL RESOURCES. 2023, 38(4): 874-884. https://doi.org/10.31497/zrzyxb.20230403

    The recent introduction of the principle of "authenticity of natural ecosystems" in the construction of national parks and the post-disaster restoration of Jiuzhaigou have triggered a debate on the issue of authenticity of natural ecosystems in the academic community. This paper systematically reviews the connotation of natural authenticity and its evolution in the international arena, and makes corresponding suggestions based on the practice of the concept of authenticity in Chinese natural protected areas. It is concluded that the issue of natural authenticity originated from the debate on whether ecological restoration was reasonable, and gradually evolved into the issue of whether to follow natural authenticity or historical authenticity in ecological restoration. Under the impetus of the Convention on Biological Diversity, the concept of ecological integrity has gradually replaced the concept of natural authenticity in ecological conservation and restoration, following the principle of combining humanism and scientism. In China's practice, however, the principle of authenticity in national parks still emphasizes historical authenticity. This study will help to better understand the principle of "authenticity" in the construction of national park systems and the ecological restoration of natural heritage in the context of increasingly frequent natural disasters and guide the management practice of natural protected areas in China.

  • ExpertWritings and Theoretical Thinking
    ZHANG Hai-xia, XUE Rui, WANG Ai-hua, ZHANG Yu-jun, YAO Lin, SUN Ying-xue, ZHANG Ting
    JOURNAL OF NATURAL RESOURCES. 2023, 38(4): 885-901. https://doi.org/10.31497/zrzyxb.20230404

    After human beings entered the age of eco-civilization, problems such as the quality decline of natural ecological environment and the deficiency of public moral consciousness have become increasingly prominent. It is urgent to find a new theoretical tool to restore the natural ecosystem and reconstruct the human public morality. The paper analyzed the genealogy of community theories, and explored the relationship between institutional development of national parks and the forming of communities. The results showed that community theory can provide a theoretical basis and a practical guidance for the national park construction. Through the analysis of the development of national park models in the world, it is found that there are three sets of relationships between the concept of national park institutions and the type of communities. Firstly, the national park on the institutional practice of right fairness vs. an abstract community for eco-space justice, which are the same ethic basis for the European countries, the countries in the New World, and China in the start-up stage of the national park construction. Secondly, the national park institutions under eco-space governance vs. a geopolitical community, which can be found in the North American and African countries which have experienced a period of human-nature conflicts and the rights deprivation of the aboriginal peoples in the national park construction. Thirdly, the national park institutions with human-nature coexistence vs. a dis-embedded imagine community which is an ideal period for the forming of emotional link cross the regions and dis-embedded community. There are three key points to promote the community-oriented national park institutions, that is to establish the legal basis for the formation of communities in national parks, to construct a foundation for common rights for the social communities, and to produce innovatively multi-agent participation mechanism for the formation of the real communities so as to provide a China solution for the promotion of the modernization of harmonious coexistence between man and nature.

  • ExpertWritings and Theoretical Thinking
    XU Fei-fei, ZHONG Xue-qing, WANG Li-jun
    JOURNAL OF NATURAL RESOURCES. 2023, 38(4): 902-917. https://doi.org/10.31497/zrzyxb.20230405

    As important symbols of beautiful China, protected areas are the core carriers of ecological civilization construction. Through content analysis with visualized software CiteSpace, this paper explores the topical changing process and characteristics of domestic study on protected areas, to penetratingly reveal the research status and problems, and put forward research prospects. The results show that: (1) The research course can be divided into three stages: the initial exploration (1998-2008), the diversified expansion (2009-2018), and the deepening development (2019-present). (2) Domestic research generally evolves from "natural resource investigation", "exploitation", "system construction", to "multi-governance". The research centers around five topics: system construction, spatial distribution and control, monitoring and evaluation of ecology, the mutual development of protected areas and community and the recreational exploitation of protected areas. Each topic presents different stage characteristics and evolution trends. (3) Based on the current research status and the new era background, the research framework of protected areas and the scientific issues of five research directions are proposed, including the deepening research on institutional construction in the context of protected areas system construction, the research on "nature-human-society" composite ecosystem of protected areas, the research on benign interaction between protected areas and communities, and the research on recreational exploitation and management of protected areas.