中国20世纪建筑遗产空间分异及形成机理

doi:10.31497/zrzyxb.20220315

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

探索20世纪建筑遗产空间分异特征与形成机理,对于提高建筑遗产的保护水平有重要意义。以396处20世纪建筑遗产为研究对象,通过标准差椭圆、重心分析、Voronoi图等空间分析方法,研究中国20世纪建筑遗产空间分异及演变特征,并运用地理探测器模型深入剖析其形成机理。研究发现：（1）从整体分异格局及演变来看,20世纪建筑遗产空间分布呈凝聚状,省域层面呈高富集区“一枝独秀”、中富集区“东部零星”、一般富集区和低富集区“两带两块”的特征;市域层面呈“断崖式”数量差异、“梯度化”等级差异、“众星捧月”空间分异特征;重心呈“先北后南”移动趋势,东西向移动较微小,集聚程度呈由强变弱趋势,集聚点数量呈递减趋势。（2）从类型分异格局及演变来看,20世纪建筑遗产可分为六大主类和16个亚类。其中,科教文卫体类、商政办公类和纪念性类遗产数量居多,且分别呈“两核分散”“东部三核、中部团状零星”“两核一环多点”空间分布特征;同时,不同类型建筑遗产分布演变特征差异明显。（3）20世纪建筑遗产空间分布格局是由区域地位、文化与教育、社会经济发展水平和对外联系等多种因素共同作用的结果,其中历史文化底蕴因子的影响最大。

关键词: 20世纪建筑遗产, 空间分异, 影响机理, 中国

Abstract:

It is of great significance to explore the spatial differentiation characteristics and formation mechanism of 20th-century architectural heritages for improving the protection level of the cultural heritages. Taking 396 architectural heritage sites of the 20th-century as the research objects, we studied their spatial differentiation and evolution characteristics by means of standard deviation ellipse, gravity center analysis, Voronoi diagram and other spatial analysis methods, and analyzed the formation mechanism of these architectural heritages by using geographic detector model. The results are shown as follows: (1) In terms of the overall differentiation pattern and evolution, the 20th-century architectural heritages are densely distributed. At the provincial level, the highly rich areas have "only one cluster", the moderately rich areas are "scattered in the east", and the slightly and non-rich areas exhibit a pattern of "two zones and two pieces". At the district level, the number difference of "cliff type", the grade difference of "gradient" and the spatial differentiation of "standing out from the crowd" are presented. The center of gravity shows a trend of "northward first, then south", while the movement from east to west is relatively slight. The degree of agglomeration shows a trend from strong to weak and the number of agglomeration points shows a trend of decline. (2) As for distribution pattern and evolution of the types, the 20th-century architectural heritages can be divided into 6 main categories and 16 subcategories, among which, the number of science, education, cultural, health, commercial and administrative offices, and memorial heritages are in the majority, showing the spatial distribution characteristics of "two cores dispersed", "three cores in the east, and scattered clusters in the middle" and "two cores, one loop and multiple points" respectively. Meanwhile, different types of architectural heritages have different distribution characteristics. (3) The spatial pattern of 20th-century architectural heritages is a result of multiple factors such as regional status, culture and education, social and economic development level and external relations, among which factors related with cultural richness in a long history have the greatest influence.

Key words: 20th-century architectural heritages, spatial differentiation, formation mechanism, China

王梓羽, 汪德根, 朱梅. 中国20世纪建筑遗产空间分异及形成机理[J]. 自然资源学报, 2022, 37(3): 784-802.

WANG Zi-yu, WANG De-gen, ZHU Mei. Spatial differentiation and formation mechanism of China's 20th-century architectural heritages[J]. JOURNAL OF NATURAL RESOURCES, 2022, 37(3): 784-802.

图/表 12

图1

图2

图3

图4

图5

图6

图7

图8

表1

表2

图9

图10

参考文献 51

[1]	单霁翔. 20世纪遗产保护的发展与特点. 当代建筑, 2020, (4):11-13.
	[ SHAN J X. Development and characteristics of 20th-century heritage protection. Contemporary Architecture, 2020, (4):11-13.]
[2]	王国强, 刘松茯. 存量时代城市建筑遗产的复杂适应性研究. 现代城市研究, 2020, (8):108-114.
	[ WANG G Q, LIU S F. Research on the complex adaptability of urban architectural heritage in the period of inventory planning. Modern Urban Research, 2020, (8):108-114.]
[3]	金磊. 中国现代经典建筑标志的呈现: 写在首届98项“中国20世纪建筑遗产”公布之际. 建筑与文化, 2017, (2):32-34.
	[ JIN L. The presentation of Chinese modern classical architectural signs: On the occasion of the first 98 China 20th-century architectural heritage. Architecture & Culture, 2017, (2):32-34.]
[4]	陈君子, 周勇, 刘大均. 中国古建筑遗产时空分布特征及成因分析. 干旱区资源与环境, 2018,32(2):194-200.
	[ CHEN J Z, ZHOU Y, LIU D J. Analysis of spatial-temporal distribution characteristics of ancient architecture heritage in China. Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment, 2018,32(2):194-200.]
[5]	李江敏, 伍青青, 柴亚朵. 我国工业遗产空间结构特征及影响因素研究. 国土资源科技管理, 2019,36(3):50-61.
	[ LI J M, WU Q Q, CHAI Y D. Spatial structural characteristics and influencing factors of Chinese industrial heritage. Scientific and Technological Management of Land and Resources, 2019,36(3):50-61.]
[6]	刘抚英, 蒋亚静, 陈易. 浙江省近现代工业遗产考察研究. 建筑学报, 2016, (2):5-9.
	[ LIU F Y, JIANG Y J, CHEN Y. An investigation of modern industrial heritages in Zhejiang province. Architectural Journal, 2016, (2):5-9.]
[7]	崔卫华, 王之禹, 徐博. 世界工业遗产的空间分布特征与影响因素. 经济地理, 2017,37(6):198-205.
	[ CUI W H, WANG Z Y, XU B. Spatial structure and determinants of world industrial heritages. Economic Geography, 2017,37(6):198-205.]
[8]	刘林丰, 谭文浩, 陈婷婷, 等. 基于百度POI数据的福州市宗教建筑分布特征研究. 四川建筑, 2020,40(3):31-33.
	[ LIU L F, TAN W H, CHEN T T, et al. A study on the distribution characteristics of religious buildings in Fuzhou based on Baidu POI data. Sichuan Architecture, 2020,40(3):31-33.]
[9]	刘军民, 郑建栋. 村落型宗教建筑遗产保护的现状、问题及对策研究: 以“韩城四庙”为例. 西北大学学报: 自然科学版, 2014,44(6):983-987.
	[ LIU J M, ZHENG J D. The protection situation, problem and countermeasure of religious architecture in village: Taking "Four Temples in Hancheng" as an example. Journal of Northwest University: Natural Science Edition, 2014,44(6):983-987.]
[10]	陈君子, 周勇, 刘大均, 等. 中国宗教建筑遗产空间分布特征及影响因素研究. 干旱区资源与环境, 2018,32(5):84-90.
	[ CHEN J Z, ZHOU Y, LIU D J, et al. Spatial distribution characteristics of religious architecture heritages in China and the influential factors. Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment, 2018,32(5):84-90.]
[11]	奚雪松, 许立言, 陈义勇. 中国文物保护单位的空间分布特征. 人文地理, 2013,28(1):75-79.
	[ XI X S, XU L Y, CHEN Y Y. Spatial distribution characteristics of national cultural retic protection units. Human Geography, 2013,28(1):75-79.]
[12]	淳庆, 杨红波, 孟哲, 等. 太原永祚寺无梁殿的建筑形制及结构静力性能研究. 文物保护与考古科学, 2019,31(6):85-91.
	[ CHUN Q, YANG H B, MENG Z, et al. Research on the architectural form and structural performance of the brick-vault hall of Yongzuo Temple. Sciences of Conservation and Archaeology, 2019,31(6):85-91.]
[13]	李爱群, 周坤朋, 王崇臣, 等. 中国古建筑木结构修复加固技术分析与展望. 东南大学学报: 自然科学版, 2019,49(1):195-206.
	[ LI A Q, ZHOU K P, WANG C C, et al. Prospective analyses on restoration and reinforcement techniques toward wooden structure of Chinese ancient architectures. Journal of Southeast University: Natural Science Edition, 2019,49(1):195-206.]
[14]	淳庆, 华一唯, 张承文, 等. 江南传统木构建筑模型修正方法研究: 以津逮楼为例. 湖南大学学报: 自然科学版, 2019,46(5):54-63.
	[ CHUN Q, HUA Y W, ZHANG C W, et al. Research on model updating methods of traditional timber buildings in the Yangtze River Region: A case study of Jindai Building. Journal of Hunan University: Natural Sciences, 2019,46(5):54-63.]
[15]	罗明金. 湘西凤凰朝阳宫古戏台建筑艺术价值研究. 民族艺术研究, 2011,24(5):85-89.
	[ LUO M J. Research on the architectural art value of the ancient stage in Phoenix Chaoyang Palace in Western Hunan. Ethnic Art Studies, 2011,24(5):85-89.]
[16]	陈红雨. 当前建筑文化遗产的艺术性保护论析. 艺术百家, 2018,34(4):152-160.
	[ CHEN H Y. An analysis of the artistic protection of current architectural cultural heritages in China. Hundred Schools in Arts, 2018,34(4):152-160.]
[17]	季宏. 我国历史建筑分类保护刍议. 新建筑, 2019, (4):96-99.
	[ JI H. Tentative discussion on classified protection of historical buildings in China. New Architecture, 2019, (4):96-99.]
[18]	朱薏婷, 廖再毅, 吴永发. 历史遗产建筑保护与更新平衡策略研究: 以加拿大于人村主街历史遗产建筑为例. 建筑学报, 2014, (4):107-112.
	[ ZHU Y T, LIAO Z Y, WU Y F. The strategies for balancing preservation and creation in the revitalization of heritage buildings: A case study of main street in Unionville, Canada. Architectural Journal, 2014, (4):107-112.]
[19]	徐进亮. 建筑遗产利用的经济评价初探. 建筑经济, 2014,35(7):81-86.
	[ XU J L. A preliminary study on economic evaluation of architectural heritage utilization. Construction Economy, 2014,35(7):81-86.]
[20]	刘佳, 过伟敏. 遗产经济学视野下城市建筑遗产的保护与再生. 生态经济, 2015,31(11):114-117.
	[ LIU J, GUO W M. Conservation and regeneration of urban architectural heritage from the perspective of heritage economics. Ecological Economy, 2015,31(11):114-117.]
[21]	冯浩城, 杨青山. 文化创意产业对东北老工业基地振兴的作用机理探究. 资源开发与市场, 2015,31(7):844-849.
	[ FENG H C, YANG Q S. Research on mechanism of cultural and creative industries to revitalization of northeast old industrial base. Resource Development & Market, 2015,31(7):844-849.]
[22]	刘敏, 刘爱利. 基于业态视角的城市建筑遗产再利用: 以北京南锣鼓巷历史街区为例. 旅游学刊, 2015,30(4):115-126.
	[ LIU M, LIU A L. Urban architectural heritage reuse from the perspective of industrial types: A case study of Nanluoguxiang street in Beijing city. Tourism Tribune, 2015,30(4):115-126.]
[23]	张天洁, 徐秋寅, 张宇威. 建筑遗产保护非政府组织的社会职责和组织能力研究. 城市发展研究, 2019,26(11):16-20.
	[ ZHANG T J, XU Q Y, ZHANG Y W. Social roles and organizational capacity of non-governmental organizations in architectural heritage preservation. Urban Development Studies, 2019,26(11):16-20.]
[24]	陈曦. 建筑遗产“修复”理论的演变及本土化研究. 中国文化遗产, 2019, (1):17-23.
	[ CHEN X. Study on the evolution and localization of the theory of "restoration" of architectural heritage. China Cultural Heritage, 2019, (1):17-23.]
[25]	MATEUS L, VEIGA M D R, DE BRITO J. In situ characterization of rammed earth wall renders. International Journal of Architectural Heritage, 2015,9(4):430-442. doi: 10.1080/15583058.2013.798714
[26]	PIZZIGATTI C, FRANZONI E. The problem of conservation of XX century architectural heritage: The fiberglass dome of the woodpecker dance club in Milano Marittima (Italy). Journal of Building Engineering, 2021,42(10):1-16.
[27]	OSELLO A, LUCIBELLO G, MORGAGNI F. HBIM and virtual tools: A new chance to preserve architectural heritage. Buildings, 2018,8(1):12, Doi: 10.3390/buildings8010012. doi: 10.3390/buildings8010012
[28]	王思思, 常郴, 孙喆, 等. 国际建筑遗产保护研究进展: 基于International Journal of Architectural Heritage 2014—2018年文章的定量分析. 科技导报, 2020,38(12):129-140.
	[ WANG S S, CHANG C, SUN Z, et al. Status and prospect of research on architectural heritage protection: A quantitative study using IJAH 2014-2018. Science & Technology Review, 2020,38(12):129-140.]
[29]	卢松, 张小军, 张业臣. 徽州传统村落的时空分布及其影响因素. 地理科学, 2018,38(10):1690-1698. doi: 10.13249/j.cnki.sgs.2018.10.013
	[ LU S, ZHANG X J, ZHANG Y C. Spatial-temporal distribution and controlling factors of traditional villages in Huizhou region. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2018,38(10):1690-1698.]
[30]	汪德根, 吕庆月, 吴永发, 等. 中国传统民居建筑风貌地域分异特征与形成机理. 自然资源学报, 2019,34(9):1864-1885.
	[ WANG D G, LYU Q Y, WU Y F, et al. The characteristic of regional differentiation and impact mechanism of architecture style of traditional residence. Journal of Natural Resources, 2019,34(9):1864-1885.]
[31]	方叶林, 黄震方, 李经龙, 等. 中国特色小镇的空间分布及其产业特征. 自然资源学报, 2019,34(6):1273-1284.
	[ FANG Y L, HUANG Z F, LI J L, et al. Spatial distribution of characteristic towns and their industrial characteristics in China. Journal of Natural Resources, 2019,34(6):1273-1284.]
[32]	王雪芹, 戚伟, 刘盛和. 中国小城镇空间分布特征及其相关因素. 地理研究, 2020,39(2):319-336. doi: 10.11821/dlyj020190173
	[ WANG X Q, QI W, LIU S H. Spatial distribution and driving factors of small towns in China. Geographical Research, 2020,39(2):319-336.]
[33]	商馨莹. 基于标准差椭圆法分析农村居民点分布特征: 以淮南市潘集区为例. 农村经济与科技, 2018,29(9):244-246.
	[ SHANG X Y. Analysis of distribution characteristics of rural residential areas based on standard deviation Ellipse method: Taking Panji district of Huainan city as an example. Rural Economy and Science-Technology, 2018,29(9):244-246.]
[34]	王洪桥, 袁家冬, 孟祥君. 东北地区A级旅游景区空间分布特征及影响因素. 地理科学, 2017,37(6):895-903. doi: 10.13249/j.cnki.sgs.2017.06.011
	[ WANG H Q, YUAN J D, MENG X J. Spatial distribution and its influencing factors of level-A scenic spots in Northeast China. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2017,37(6):895-903.]
[35]	佘冰, 叶信岳, 房会会, 等. 基于局部聚类的网络Voronoi图生成方法研究. 地理科学, 2015,35(5):637-643. doi: 10.13249/j.cnki.sgs.2015.05.637
	[ SHE B, YE X Y, FANG H H, et al. A method for integrating network Voronoi and spatial clustering. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2015,35(5):637-643.]
[36]	王新生, 郭庆胜, 姜友华. 一种用于界定经济客体空间影响范围的方法: Voronoi图. 地理研究, 2000,19(3):311-315. doi: 10.11821/yj2000030013
	[ WANG X S, GUO Q S, JIANG Y H. A new approach to delimitate influenced coverage of an economic object: Voronoi diagram. Geographical Research, 2000,19(3):311-315.]
[37]	刘昌雪, 汪德根, 李凤. 国家水利风景区空间格局演变及影响机理分析. 地理与地理信息科学, 2018,34(4):108-117.
	[ LIU C X, WANG D G, LI F. Analysis on spatial pattern evolution of the national water scenic areas and its influencing mechanism. Geography and Geo-Information Science, 2018,34(4):108-117.]
[38]	DUYCKAERTS C, GODEFROY G. Voronoi tessellation to study the numerical density and the spatial distribution of neurons. Journal of Chemical Neuroanatomy, 2000,20:83-92. doi: 10.1016/S0891-0618(00)00064-8
[39]	王劲峰, 徐成东. 地理探测器: 原理与展望. 地理学报, 2017,72(1):116-134. doi: 10.11821/dlxb201701010
	[ WANG J F, XU C D. Geodetector: Principle and prospective. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2017,72(1):116-134.]
[40]	李莉, 侯国林, 夏四友, 等. 成都市休闲旅游资源空间分布特征及影响因素. 自然资源学报, 2020,35(3):683-697.
	[ LI L, HOU G L, XIA S Y, et al. Spatial distribution characteristics and influencing factors of leisure tourism resources in Chengdu. Journal of Natural Resources, 2020,35(3):683-697.]
[41]	刘彦随, 杨忍. 中国县域城镇化的空间特征与形成机理. 地理学报, 2012,67(8):1011-1020. doi: 10.11821/xb201208001
	[ LIU Y S, YANG R. Spatial characteristics and formation mechanism of the county urbanization in China. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2012,67(8):1011-1020.]
[42]	曹智, 刘彦随, 李裕瑞, 等. 中国专业村镇空间格局及其影响因素. 地理学报, 2020,75(8):1647-1666. doi: 10.11821/dlxb202008007
	[ CAO Z, LIU Y S, LI Y R, et al. Spatial pattern and its influencing factors of specialized villages and towns in China. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2020,75(8):1647-1666.]
[43]	朱佩娟, 郎泽慧, 贺清云, 等. 长沙城市空间破碎化的格局特征及其影响因素. 地理研究, 2020,39(8):1739-1754. doi: 10.11821/dlyj020191108
	[ ZHU P J, LANG Z H, HE Q Y, et al. The pattern characteristics and influencing factors of urban spatial fragmentation in Changsha. Geographical Research, 2020,39(8):1739-1754.]
[44]	常青. 回眸一瞥: 中国20世纪建筑遗产的范型及其脉络. 建筑遗产, 2019, (3):1-10.
	[ CHANG Q. On the form models and their context of the China's 20th-century heritage architecture. Heritage Architecture, 2019, (3):1-10.]
[45]	汪红蕾. 第四批中国20世纪建筑遗产项目公布. 建筑, 2019, (24):35.
	[ WANG H L. The fourth batch of China's 20th century architectural heritage projects has been announced. Construction and Architecture, 2019, (24):35.]
[46]	胡诗文, 陈金华. 基于GIS的历史文化名城空间分异与影响因素研究. 乐山师范学院学报, 2016,31(4):61-66.
	[ HU S W, CHEN J H. Research on spatial differentiation and influential factors of historical and cultural cities based on GIS. Journal of Leshan Normal University, 2016,31(4):61-66.]
[47]	程乾, 凌素培. 中国非物质文化遗产的空间分布特征及影响因素分析. 地理科学, 2013,33(10):1166-1172. doi: 10.13249/j.cnki.sgs.2013.010.1166
	[ CHENG Q, LING S P. Geographical distribution and affecting factors of the intangible cultural heritage in China. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2013,33(10):1166-1172.]
[48]	杨柳. 浅论中国古建筑遗产的分布与原因. 文物鉴定与鉴赏, 2019, (21):140-141.
	[ YANG L. A brief discussion on the distribution and causes of China's ancient architectural heritage. Identification and Appreciation to Cultural Relics, 2019, (21):140-141.]
[49]	高路. 民国以来20世纪前半叶中国城市化水平研究回顾. 江汉大学学报: 社会科学版, 2014,31(6):26-31.
	[ GAO L. A review of research on China's urbanization in the first half of the 20th century since the founding of the Republic of China. Journal of Jianghan University: Social Science Edition, 2014,31(6):26-31.]
[50]	郑伟民. 社会经济因素对区域经济发展的影响: 兼论我国经济重心的地域移动. 人文地理, 1991,6(1):51-56.
	[ ZHENG W M. The influence of social and economic factors on reginal economic development: On reginal movement of the Chinese national economic core. Human Geography, 1991,6(1):51-56.]
[51]	覃丽君, 金晓斌, 蒋宇超, 等. 近六百年来长江三角洲地区城镇空间与城镇体系格局演变分析. 地理研究, 2019,38(5):1045-1062. doi: 10.11821/dlyj020170862
	[ QIN L J, JIN X B, JIANG Y C, et al. The spatial pattern of urban areas and urban system of Yangtze River Delta in the past 600 years. Geographical Research, 2019,38(5):1045-1062.]

目标层	准则层	因子层	指标解释	指标来源
建筑遗产空间分异	区域地位ξ₁	历史地位X₁	是否曾为古代都城	[11]
	区域地位ξ₁	政治地位X₂	行政区划	[4]
	文化与教育ξ₂	历史文化底蕴X₃	全国重点文物保护单位数量密度值	[46, 47]
	文化与教育ξ₂	教育水平X₄	高校数量/个	[4, 48]
	社会经济发展水平ξ₃	人口密度X₅	城市人口数量与面积比值	[4, 11, 48]
		城镇化水平X₆	人口城镇化率/%	[8, 46]
		人均GDP X₇	人均GDP/元	[4, 5, 10, 48]
	对外联系ξ₄	交通区位X₈	交通枢纽层级	[5, 6, 10]
	对外联系ξ₄	公路网络密度X₉	城市公路总里程与面积比值	[5, 8]

	区域地位ξ₁		文化与教育ξ₂		社会经济发展水平ξ₃			对外联系ξ₄
	历史地位 X₁	政治地位 X₂	历史文化底蕴 X₃	教育水平 X₄	人口密度 X₅	城镇化水平 X₆	人均GDP X₇	交通区位 X₈	公路网络密度 X₉
q	0.106	0.483^*	0.608^*	0.387^*	0.539^*	0.492^*	0.389^*	0.432^*	0.049
P	0.013	0.005	0.000	0.000	0.000	0.000	0.000	0.000	0.247