旅行费用法在旅游资源价值评估中的若干问题述评

doi:10.11849/zrzyxb.2011.11.017

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 旅行费用法(TCM)是一种基于观测资料评估旅游资源价值的显示偏好法。论文在文献梳理的基础上,对TCM研究过程中的偏差进行了述评,并指出了可能的解决方案;然后,讨论了TCM的有效性、适用性以及合法性,并提出进一步研究的重点和方向。文献综述表明:常见的TCM模型可以分为ZTCM、TCIA、GTCM、ITCM、HTCM和RUM六种类型,在研究中应根据实际情况选择合适的模型;旅行费用测度中的内生分层、抽样误差、时间的机会成本计算、多目的地之间的费用分成等问题,需求函数估算中的多重共线性、内生性、函数形式的选择等问题,均会导致评估结果出现偏差;TCM在发展中国家的有效性、适用性和合法性遭到了质疑,但仍不失为一种评估旅游资源价值的有效手段;今后的研究要加强TCM中的偏差分析及有效性检验,并着力于模型的修正和改进,加强TCM与CVM的结合,提高研究方法的有效性。

关键词: 资源经济学, 旅行费用法(TCM), 旅游资源, 游憩价值

Abstract: Travel Cost Method (TCM) is a revealed preference approach for valuing tourist resources based on observed economic behavior. In TCM research, several problems, including selecting model, measuring travel cost and estimating the demand function, are controversial. Based on the literature review and analysis, this paper discusses the biases in TCM research and puts forward some solutions respectively. After that, the validity, applicability and legality of TCM are discussed and the emphasis and direction of the future research are proposed. The result of literature review shows that: 1) there are six categories of TCM, including ZTCM, TCIA, GTCM, ITCM, HTCM and RUM; 2) the following problems, which include endogenous stratification, sampling errors, opportunity cost of time and multi-destination trip during the measurement of travel cost, and multi-colinearity, endogeneity and the choice of function form during the estimation of recreational demand function, may lead to biases in TCM valuation; 3) although there are various defects in validity in developing countries, and its applicability and legality are controversial, TCM is still an effective method to measure the recreational value of tourist resources; and 4) the development of TCM should shift gradually from case study to bias analysis and validity test, and then, modification and improvement of the TCM model, especially the combination of the TCM and CVM, should be emphasized to establish and perfect the TCM implementation rules that are suitable to developing countries.

Key words: resource economics, Travel Cost Method (TCM), tourist resources, recreational value

中图分类号:

F062.1

董雪旺, 张捷, 章锦河. 旅行费用法在旅游资源价值评估中的若干问题述评[J]. 自然资源学报, 2011, 26(11): 1983-1997.

DONG Xue-wang, ZHANG Jie, ZHANG Jin-he. Review on Several Issues of Travel Cost Method in Tourist Resources Valuation[J]. JOURNAL OF NATURAL RESOURCES, 2011, 26(11): 1983-1997.

参考文献

[1] Hotelling H. The economics of public recreation . Washington: The Prewitt Report, National Parks Service, 1947. [2] Clawson M. Methods for Measuring the Demand for and Value of Outdoor Recreation [M]. Washington: Resources for the Future, Inc.,1959. [3] US Water Resources Council. Economic and environmental principles and guidelines for water and related land resources implementation studies . Washington D C: US Government Printing Office, 1983. [4] Anex R P. A travel-cost method of evaluating household hazardous waste disposal services [J]. Journal of Environmental Management,1995,45:189-198. [5] Clarke P M. Cost-benefit analysis and mammographic screening: A travel cost approach [J]. Journal of Health Economics,1998,17: 767-787. [6] Jeuland M, Lucas M, Clemens J, et al. Estimating the private benefits of vaccination against cholera in Beira, Mozambique: A travel cost approach [J]. Journal of Development Economics,2010(91):310-322. [7] Randall A. A difficulty with the travel cost method [J]. Land Economics,1994,70(1):88-96. [8] Feather P, Shaw W D. Estimating the cost of leisure time for recreation demand models [J]. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management,1999,38:49-65. [9] Garrod G, Willis K G. Economic Valuation of the Environment: Methods and Case Studies [M]. U K: Edward Elgar,1999. [10] 李巍,李文军.用改进的旅行费用法评估九寨沟的游憩价值[J].北京大学学报:自然科学版,2003,39(4):548-555. [11] 张茵,蔡运龙.基于分区的多目的地TCM模型及其在游憩资源价值评估中的应用——以九寨沟自然保护区为例[J].自然资源学报,2004,19(5):651-661. [12] 周慧滨,左旦平.旅行成本法在我国应用中存在的几个问题[J].自然资源学报,2006,21(3):489-499. [13] 谢双玉,訾瑞昭,许英杰,等.旅行费用区间分析法与分区旅行费用法的比较及应用[J].旅游学刊,2008,23(2):41-45. [14] 赵玲,王尔大,苗翠翠.ITCM在我国游憩价值评估中的应用及改进[J].旅游学刊,2009,24(3):63-69. [15] 查爱苹,邱洁威,姜红.旅行费用法若干问题研究[J].旅游学刊,2010,25(1):37-32. [16] Ward F, Roach B, Loomis J, et al. Regional recreation demand models for large reservoirs: Database development, model estimation, and management applications . Final Report (March) to U. S. Army Corps of Engineers Waterways Experiment Station, Technical Report R-96-2, Vicksburg, MS,1996. [17] Kanaan G, Day H. Recreational demand at lakes and reservoirs [J]. Journal of the Urban Planning and Development Division, 1973,99(2):265-269. [18] Wade W, McCollister G, McCann R, et al. Recreation benefits for California reservoirs: A multisite facilities-augmented gravity travel cost model . Submitted to Jones & Stokes Associates under contract to the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation,1988. [19] Brown W G, Nawas F. Impact of aggregation on the estimation of outdoor recreation demand functions [J]. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,1973,55:246-249. [20] Shaw W D. Searching for the opportunity cost of an individual’s time [J]. Land Economics,1992,68:107-115. [21] Smith V K, Kaoru Y. Modeling recreation demand within a random utility framework [J]. Economics Letters,1986,22(4): 395-399. [22] Bockstael N, Hanemann W M, Kling C. Estimating the value of water quality improvements in a recreational demand framework [J]. Water Resources Research,1987,23(5):951-960. [23] Brown G J, Mendelsohn R. The hedonic travel cost method [J]. The Review of Economics and Statistics,1984, 66: 427-433. [24] Lancaster K J. A new approach to consumer theory [J]. The Journal of Political Economy,1966,74(2):132-157. [25] Cropper M, Deck L, Kishor N, et al. Valuing product attributes using single market data: A comparison of hedonic and discrete choice approaches [J]. Review of Economics and Statistics,1993,75(2):225-232. [26] Smith V K, Kaoru Y. The hedonic travel cost method: A view from the trenches [J]. Land Economics,1987,63:779-792. [27] Bateman I J, Garrod G D, Brainard J S, et al. Measurement issues in the travel cost method: A geographical information systems approach [J]. Journal of Agricultural Economics,1996,47(2):191-205. [28] Brainard J S, Lovett A A, Bateman I J. Using isochrone surfaces in travel cost models [J]. Journal of Transport Geography,1997, 5(2): 117-126. [29] Stynes D J, White E M. Reflections on measuring recreation and travel spending [J]. Journal of Travel Research,2006,45(8): 8-16. [30] Shaw D. On-site samples’ regression: Problems of non-negative integers, truncation, and endogenous stratification [J]. Journal of Econometrics,1988,37:211-223. [31] Loomis J B. Travel cost demand model based river recreation benefit estimates with on-site and household surveys: Comparative results and a correction procedure [J]. Water Resources Research,2003,39(4):1105-1108. [32] Chaudhry P, Tewari V P. A comparison between TCM and CVM in assessing the recreational use value of urban forestry [J]. International Forestry Review,2006,8(4):439-448. [33] Knetsch J L. Outdoor recreation demands and benefits [J]. Land Economics,1963,39:387-396. [34] Smith R J, Kavangh N J. The measurement of Benefits of trout fishing: Preliminary results of a study at Gratham water house water authority, Huningdonshire [J]. Journal of Leisure Research,1969,1:316-322. [35] Cesario F J. Value of time in recreation benefit studies [J]. Land Economics,1976,55:32-41. [36] Willis K G, Benson J F. Recreational values of forests [J]. Forestry,1989,62(2):93-109. [37] Alvarez-Farizo B, Hanley N, Barberan R. The value of leisure time: A contingent rating approach [J]. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management,2001,44(5):681-699. [38] 张冬青,宁宣熙.考虑收入因素的旅行时间价值模型研究[J].系统工程学报,2006,21(1):1-5. [39] 吕君,汪宇明,刘丽梅. 草原生态系统旅游价值的评估——以内蒙古自治区四子王旗为例[J].旅游学刊,2006,21(8):69-74. [40] 许抄军,罗能生,刘沛林,等.历史文化古城游憩利用价值评估——以凤凰古城为例[J].经济地理,2006,26(3):521-525. [41] 黄茂祝,徐波,张杰,等.汤旺河国家公园游憩价值评价研究[J].森林工程,2009,25(6):18-21. [42] Loomis J B, Yorizane S, Larson D. Testing significance of multi-destination and multi-purpose trips effects in a travel cost method demand model for whale watching trips [J]. Agricultural and Resource Economics Review,2000,29:183-191. [43] Kuosmanen T, Nillesen E, Wesseler J. Does ignoring multidestination trips in the travel cost method cause a systematic bias? [J] The Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics,2004,48(4):629-651. [44] 郭剑英,王乃昂.旅游资源的旅游价值评估——以敦煌为例[J].自然资源学报,2004,19(6):811-817. [45] 郭剑英.乐山大佛旅游资源的国内旅游价值评估[J].地域研究与开发,2007,26(6):104-107. [46] 许丽忠,张江山,王菲凤,等.熵权多目的地TCM模型及其在游憩资源旅游价值评估中的应用——以武夷山景区为例[J].自然资源学报,2007,22(1):28-36. [47] Hajkowicz S A, McDonald G T, Smith P N. An evaluation of multiple objective decision support weighting techniques in natural resource management [J]. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management,2000,43:505-518. [48] Mendelsohn R, Hof J, Peterson G, et al. Measuring recreation values with multiple destination trips [J]. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,1992,74:926-933. [49] Beal D J. A travel cost analysis of the value of Carnarvon Gorge national park for recreational use [J]. Review of Marketing and Agricultural Economics,1995,63:292-303. [50] 董雪旺,张捷,蔡永寿,等.基于旅行费用法的九寨沟旅游资源游憩价值评估[J].地域研究与开发,待刊. [51] Murdock J. Handling unobserved site characteristics in random utility models of recreation demand [J]. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management,2006,51:1-25. [52] OECD.环境项目和政策的经济评价指南[M].施涵,陈松,译.北京:中国环境科学出版社,1996:49-121. [53] 孙睿君,钟笑寒.运用旅行费用模型估计典型消费者的旅游需求及其收益:对中国的实证研究[J].统计研究,2005(12):34-39. [54] 赵强,李秀梅,王乃昂,等.旅行费用法两种技术路线的应用比较[J].南京林业大学学报:自然科学版,2009,33(1):106-110. [55] 董雪旺,张捷,刘传华,等.条件价值法中的偏差分析及信度和效度检验——以九寨沟游憩价值评估为例[J].地理学报,2011, 66(2):267-278. [56] Smith V K, Desvouges W H, Fisher A. A comparison of direct and indirect methods for estimating environmental benefits [J]. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,1986,68:280-290. [57] Hanley N D. Valuing rural recreation benefits: An empirical comparison of two approaches [J]. Journal of Agricultural Economics,1989,40(3):361-374. [58] Loomis J B, Creel M, Park T A. Comparing benefit estimates from travel cost and contingent valuation using confidence intervals for Hicksian welfare measures [J]. Applied Economics,1991,23(11):1725-31. [59] 肯尼思·D·贝利.现代社会研究方法[M].许真,译.上海:上海人民出版社,1986:90-101. [60] Carson R T, Flores N E, Martin K M, et al. Contingent valuation and revealed preference methodologies: Comparing the estimates for quasi-public goods [J]. Land Economics,1996,71(1):80-99. [61] Loomis J B, González J M. Evaluating recreational benefits of water resources on small geographical areas: An application to rivers in Puerto Rico //Proceedings of Conference of Hydrology Days. 27th Annual American Geophysical Union (AGU), Colorado State University, 2007. [62] 郭剑英,王乃昂.敦煌旅游资源非使用价值评估[J].资源科学,2005,27(5):188-192. [63] 熊明均,郭剑英,邓丹.利用意愿调查价值评估法(CVM) 评估旅游资源的非使用价值——以乐山大佛景区为例[J].中共乐山市委党校学报:新论,2007,9(3):76-78. [64] 许丽忠,吴春山,王菲凤,等.条件价值法评估旅游资源非使用价值的可靠性检验[J].生态学报,2007,27(10):4302-4309. [65] 张茵,蔡运龙.用条件估值法评估九寨沟的游憩价值——CVM 方法的校正与比较[J].经济地理,2010,30(7):1205-1211. [66] 李京梅,刘铁鹰.基于旅行费用法和意愿调查法的青岛滨海游憩资源价值评估[J].旅游科学,2010,24(4):49-59. [67] DONG Xue-wang, ZHANG Jie, ZHI Rui-zhi, et al. Measuring recreational value of world heritage sites based on contingent valuation method: A case study of Jiuzhaigou [J]. Chinese Geographical Science,2011,21(1):119-128. [68] 马中.环境与资源经济学概论[M].北京: 高等教育出版社,1999:130-131. [69] Eberle W D, Hayden F G. Critique of contingent valuation and travel cost methods for valuing natural resources and ecosystems [J]. Journal of Economic Issues,1991,25(3):649-687. [70] Cummings R G, Borokshire D S, Schulze W D. Valuing the Environmental Goods: A State of the Arts Assessment of the Contingent Valuation [M]. Totowa, N J: Roweman and Allnaheld,1986. [71] Cameron T A. Combining contingent valuation and travel cost data for the valuation of nonmarket goods [J]. Land Economics, 1992,68:302-317. [72] Louviere J J, Hensher D A, Swait J D. Stated Choice Methods: Analysis and Application [M]. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,2000. [73] Whitehead J C. Combining willingness to pay and behavior data with limited information [J]. Resource and Energy Economics, 2005,27(2):143-155.